The arduous journey of Ameer Minai’s collection of books, letters and manuscripts
A vanishing world
By Dr Ali Gibran Siddiqui and Sameen HayatPhotos by Manal Khan
Faded and speckled with white paint, the thick black nast‘alīq script on the gate reminds visitors that this bungalow in Karachi is inhabited by Āl-e-Mīnā, or the descendants of a 15th century Siddiqui Sufi Shaykh, Makhdum Shah Mina. The Shaykh himself is buried more than a thousand kilometers east of this residence, in a Lucknow neighbourhood that was once known as Mina Bazaar — after him. Despite this physical divide, a heady mixture of nostalgia, memory and tradition connects the house of Āl-e-Mīnā with not just Lucknow, but also Rampur and Hyderabad of yore.
The custodian of these memories, and the main resident of this house, is Israil Ahmed Minai. At 94, he exhibits a photographic memory as he guides visitors through events spread over the whole of last century. The memories he received from his own parents take him even further back – before his own birth – to the mid-19th century. For Israil, it is a source of immense family pride that his grandfather was the scholar and poet Ameer Ahmed Minai. Despite living in the pre-Partition Subcontinent of Ghalib and Dagh Dehlvi, Ameer Minai’s diverse interests and works made him a singular talent — not of the stature of his esteemed contemporaries but comfortably commanding his own space and respect.
Ameer Minai was born into a family of Awadhi literati in Lucknow in 1829. He was raised and trained in the ways of tasawuf like his ancestor Shah Mina. “He could initiate people in all five of the tariqas (Sufi orders),” explains his grandson. Ameer Minai also remained intensely devoted to his own pīr (mentor), Mian Ameer Shah Sahib of the Naqshbandi-Mujaddadi tariqa, and often imagined their relationship like that between his namesake and ideal, Ameer Khusrau, and Nizamuddin Auliya.
A curious mind, with a keen eye for detail, Ameer Minai would take note of all that he experienced in Lucknow. The buildings, gardens, marketplaces, idioms, games and riddles — everything he heard, saw and experienced remained firmly etched in his memory.
The tale of Ameer Minai’s affection for his beloved city, like most tales of love, is tragic. During the tumultuous months of 1857, he saw his neighbourhood torn apart and set ablaze by British cannon fire. The fire raged through his house, leaving his precious library in cinders. The consequent downfall of the princely state of Awadh, which patronised poets and artists, forced Ameer Minai to look for employment elsewhere.
He left the gutted Mina Bazaar behind and soon found employment with Nawab Yusuf Ali Khan Bahadur of Rampur, a potentate ruling a British protectorate two hundred or so kilometres north-east of Delhi. The rulers of this relatively new Rohilla-Pashtun dynasty sought to legitimise their position through a method employed by Muslim rulers in India for centuries: they patronised poets. “Whenever Ghalib, who had spent all his money on drink and dice, sought to flee his creditors, he would find his way up north to Rampur. The Nawab would pay off the debts while Ghalib enjoyed the famous mangoes of Rampur. He also received the kingly sum of 200 rupees as a monthly stipend,” says Israil. “My grandfather, too, received patronage from Nawab Yusuf Ali Khan after he was left destitute in the aftermath of 1857.”
He recounts how his grandfather’s life in Rampur was one marked by prosperity and respect as he composed countless works of both poetry and prose. With the Nawab’s generous patronage, the Minai family, initially left behind in Lucknow, followed Ameer Minai’s footsteps and landed in Rampur. In their new place of residence, Āl-e-Mīnā, were able to enjoy half a century of financial and social stability. Nawab Yusuf Ali Khan’s generosity was continued by his successor, Nawab Kalb-e-Ali Khan.
Succeeding rulers were less generous than their predecessors but Ameer Minai benefitted from the regency of General Azeemuddin Khan who, in the 1890s, ensured that the first two volumes of his dictionary, Amīr al-lughāt, were published. Support for this project waned with Azeemuddin’s death and Ameer Minai felt he had to look for other sources of funding.
The ruler of the state of Hyderabad Deccan at that time, Nizam Mahbub Ali Khan Asaf Jah VI, was known for his extravagant lifestyle that included a liberal patronage of the arts; he had already funded the publication of Farhang-e Āṣafīyya, now famous for being the first fully-published Urdu dictionary. Ameer Minai decided to appeal to the Nizam’s sense of pride in the Urdu language and headed to Deccan in 1900.
Ameer Minai would never make the journey back to Rampur where his family still lived. Deccani climate, his age and the pressing need for funding contributed to his death a mere month after his arrival in Hyderabad.
While he was buried in Hyderabad, most of his library remained in Rampur. The new rulers in the princely state were not pleased with his attempt to seek alternate means of patronage and funding and, in a moment of royal anger, cut off all stipends to Āl-e-Mīnā. With this new-found destitution, Ameer Minai’s children were forced to sell off their belongings – furniture, books and letters from his own collection – as scrap.
Eventually, Hakim Ajmal Khan, famous for founding the Jamia Millia University in Delhi, came to know of this turn of events and decided to intervene. He organised a mushāira, presided over by the Nawab of Rampur, where the superiority of Ameer Minai’s verse over that of his contemporaries was underscored repeatedly. The Nawab was also reminded how such sweet verse flowed freely under the patronage of his esteemed ancestors. Not wishing to be outdone by his departed predecessors, he offered employment to Muhammad Ahmed Minai, Ameer Minai’s son, as a poet. In was an ironic development since Muhammad Ahmed Minai considered poetry to be an intellectual and pecuniary waste.
After Muhammad Ahmed Minai’s death in 1933, his eldest son, and Israil’s eldest brother, Ismail Ahmed Minai, made his way to Hyderabad Deccan. One by one, the rest of the family, including Israil, followed him. Along with them also moved Ameer Minai’s collection of books and manuscripts. The whole family stayed in Hyderabad for around 10 years before gradually making their way to Karachi around 1947.
In the tumultuous times around the Partition of the Subcontinent, a tiny apartment provided refuge for the family and also for Ameer Minai’s collection. With the passage of time, as the various children of Āl-e-Mīnā were able to gain employment, the family moved out to more affluent neighbourhoods in Karachi. Over the next six decades or so, the collection travelled around the city with Israil’s elder brother Idris Ahmed Minai because he changed houses several times. It was last housed at his apartment in Clifton till he died in 2009.